Several MSPmentor readers allege Kaseya can never pursue an initial public offering (IPO) because CEO Gerald Blackie (pictured) had a previous run-in with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). In order to address — and eliminate — the rumors, a Kaseya spokesman sent MSPmentor a comprehensive statement. Take a look.
First, the short version of Kaseya’s response. According to a Kaseya spokesman:
- No criminal complaint was ever filed against Blackie.
- Blackie never knowingly defrauded anyone: not the employees of Platinum (his previous employer) nor its public investors.
- Without admitting any wrongdoing, in May 1996 Blackie reached a settlement in a civil action filed by the SEC.
- Kaseya is fully capable of going public, with or without Blackie as CEO.
Try not to read too much into that last line about Blackie’s status as CEO. The spokesman, I believe, was simply making the case that no single person controls Kaseya’s destiny. However, I have a feeling Blackie will remain with Kaseya for years to come.
Kaseya’s Complete Statement
Now, here’s a look at the complete statement from Kaseya:
“Here are the facts according to the SEC: Without admitting any wrongdoing, in May of 1996 Blackie reached a settlement in a civil action filed by the SEC, requiring him to pay a fine, return proceeds of stock sales to Platinum Software that occurred during the accounting restatement period and to agree not to be an officer or director of a public company for 10 years.
The settlement was a result of a complex and technical alleged violation of the securities laws stemming from the simple pre-programmed sales of small amounts of stock once a quarter. This creates the capacity for the government to allege insider trading in such cases where, for example, a restatement of revenues is necessary. It must be said that in the case of Platinum, these were re-categorizations of the financials; revenue to deferred revenue, for example.
Mr. Blackie felt that it was easier to settle with the SEC than to spend five years in the courts trying to clear his name since the outside directors, then running the company, were quite happy to make Blackie the villain. The settlement agreement with the SEC has since expired. No criminal complaint was ever filed. Kaseya is fully capable of going public, with or without Blackie as CEO.
Mr. Blackie never knowingly defrauded anyone: not the employees of Platinum nor its public investors. It was Blackie himself who asked for an investigation into whether proper accounting procedures had been followed. During the period in which there were revenue recognition issues, he sold less than 3% of his stock. Platinum software had won several industry awards and was widely regarded as being the best in its class. However, the company was growing at a frenetic pace, with undoubtedly too many moving parts, and Mr. Blackie admits to having been a young, naïve CEO, ill-equipped to navigate that kind of crisis, and who was subsequently taken advantage of by the very outside board members who were asked to conduct the independent investigation. The events at issue in the settlement all took place back in the early 90’s, more than 15 years ago. Mr. Blackie has remained in compliance with his obligations to that SEC settlement.”
How the Chatter Started
Rumors about Blackie’s status with the SEC started in June 2008, when MSPmentor posted a story about Kaseya’s decision to remain privately held. Several reader comments — posted over a series of weeks and months — alleged that Blackie had problems with the SEC that would prevent him from running a public company. Clearly, Kaseya claims otherwise.
MSPmentor is updated multiple times daily. Don’t miss a single post. Subscribe to our Enewsletter, RSS and Twitter feeds and Resource Center.
Read More About This Topic
Share This Post
Posted In: MSP Mentor
Tags: Gerald Blackie Platinum Software | Gerald Blackie SEC Investigation | Kaseya CEO Gerald Blackie
Interact: Add a Comment | Trackback Link | Permalink
Subscribe: RSS Feed
Get Started: Visit our new 
An interesting observation: traffic to this blog entry is high but reader comments are low (zero…). I wonder — where are the readers who made the allegations about Blackie now? We’d like to hear from you. Kaseya’s response to the allegations seems pretty strong to me. And the number of Platinum Software veterans who remain loyal to Blackie also is high.
By my very nature I give people the benefit of the doubt. Am I defending Blackie? I guess so. Full disclosure: MSPmentor has done business with Kaseya. And Blackie always sits down for an interview when I reach out to him.
But that doesn’t stop me/MSPmentor from asking the hard questions in this industry. And our readers will always have the power to weigh in with comments to ensure your voices and opinions are heard as well. (Translation: If you think our coverage misses the mark you’re free to slam us on our own comment boards.)
Kaseya plans to remain private. If the company ever pursues an IPO with Blackie as CEO, we’ll finally see if Wall Street considers Blackie’s old SEC settlement an issue.
Thanks for the official comment, Kaseya.
-jp
So I didn’t know this before and went on to google it:
http://classaction.findlaw.com/cases/securities/sec/sec1/files/1998/lr14905.html
This is what they did (allegibly)
” In addition, the Complaint alleges, Blackie, Erickson and
Tague each sold Platinum common stock while they were in
possession of adverse material non-public information about
Platinum’s true financial condition, thereby avoiding trading
losses of $1,018,000, $498,000 and $960,000, respectively.
Blackie, Erickson and Tague also received bonuses of $128,125,
$50,000 and $6,000, respectively, during the period of the
alleged fraud based upon Platinum’s purportedly strong financial
performance.”
so they paid some fines….
“directing Blackie and Tague to pay civil money penalties of
$100,000 and $50,000, respectively”
So Blackie’s (alleged) losses cut down from: $1,018,000 to $100,000
I’m starting to hate the internet. You can sometimes dig up too much information.
I say, skip the drama and go with labtech (www.labtechsoft.com)
Rafal